Heinous rape and murder in katra, Uttar Pradesh

May 28-29,2014: The horrific rape and murder of 2 teenage sisters in Katra, Uttar Pradesh has brought shame to all of us. The gruesome hanging of the victims to the tree was the most barbaric act the culprits committed. It simply exhibits their insanity and insensitivity. However, I was appalled by the agonizing delay that happened in police reaching the crime scene and cordoning the area so that the whole world could have been  spared of the insensitive way the hanging bodies were displayed by the media. It has been reported by the media that the girls belong to Dalit families.
Violence (including sexual) against women has its roots in societal attitudes. However, lax law and order situation also adds to the problem. The society can not absolve itself of the guilt that we all share when such cases happen. Similarly, the ignorance and misplaced notions of the political class with regard to violence against females just halts the process of more stringent laws to tackle the problem. I am reminded of a recent highly irresponsible statement by none other than Mulayam Singh Yadav whose land witnessed this unfortunate incidence. Mr. Mulayam Singh Yadav had said on an occasion:” Boys will be boys. They make mistakes.”

Let us hope the police and justice system will act in a swifter manner to bring some healing  to the aggrieved families.

 

Your India Tomorrow: An Open Letter to Young Indians by Kishore Asthana

This article penned down by Mr. Kishore Asthana is being reproduced as a Guest Article. Mr Asthana is a socio-political activist based out of Gurgaon. He can be reached via his email asthana1 [at] yahoo.com
———————————–
Hi,
 
You do not know me. However, that does not matter. I was born a couple of years before our independence and, over the last six decades I have seen India becoming less tolerant, more cynical, more corrupt and less ably run. We have now reached a level where you are staring in the face of a catastrophe. If you do not do anything about this, your next generation will suffer through this. All the omens are already there.
I will perhaps not be there to see your grandchildren but my children and grandchildren will be there and your children, too. They will be living in the India they inherit from you.This is why this message is important for you.
It is for you to take action at this point or all is lost. At a similar point in history, what Brutus tells Cassius in Julius Caesar is equally relevant for you:
 
“There is a tide in the affairs of men, which, taken at the flood, leads on to fortune;
 Omitted, all the voyage of their life
’s bound in shallows and in miseries.
On such a full sea are we now afloat,
And we must take the current when it serves,
 or lose our ventures.”
Brutus says this because “the enemy increaseth every day.” As it did for Brutus and Cassius, the enemy increases for you, too and, unchecked, it will overwhelm you and your children.
Let us imagine what kind of India we could have had if the enemy had not been so dominant. You would have a country where:
·    You open the tap at any time of the day and night anywhere in India and you get pure drinking water. No need for water purifiers.
·    You switch on the power at any time and the light goes on. No inverters or generators. Industries can run uninterrupted by power cuts.
·    You want to get your child admitted to school and you do not have to pay a fortune or stand in long lines. Perhaps you can do it online.
·    There is a choice of good public school, where the standard of education is second to none.
·    It you want to go from town A to town B, you could drive on a clean, broad highway without having to stop for paying tolls.
·    You want to go for an evening walk and you can do so without the danger of stepping into garbage, getting run over by a car, twisting your ankle in a pothole or getting mugged. There are cycle tracks and pedestrian walkways. Even ramps for the handicapped.
·    You can go out of town without worrying about your house being burgled.
·    The Police Station is a welcoming place instead of a place to be feared.
·    A case in the court does not take years and years and the guilty are punished promptly and fairly.
·    A country where the rule of law prevails and the law does not get manipulated by those in power. When the ministers opine, “the law will take its own course” as they do in every case, the law is allowed to take its own course with speed and fairness. Where Commissions of enquiry are really effective and quick instead of becoming interminable sinecures for retired judges and others.
.  A country where your voice is heard not only pretend-heard during election time and forgotten thereafter.
·    Where none of those who make laws for you and me are themselves criminals.
Most of these and many other such things are taken for granted by the residents of many other countries. Why can we not enjoy them here?
However improbable this happening in India may occur at first glance, it is possible for us to have these too – and fairly easily. The reason I say this is because resources are not the constraint, our will and ability to ensure their honest usage is.
Yes, we have more than enough resources. However, most of these do not go into the implementation of schemes. They are stolen by the corrupt. We have become a country that attracts comments from leaders abroad mentioning that bribery is a natural thing in India and that no deals are possible without paying bribes. The truth is borne out by our scams.
If you care to go through the depressing details of all the scams in India where massive amounts of money has been fraudulently taken away, do visit. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_scandals_in_India#2000s
This site lists all major scams. You will be surprised at the sheer number. However, for a young person, it is very necessary to learn what kind of a country we are living in.
Just the following five scandals will illustrate what I mean:
Scandal
Year reported
Scope
Location
Key players
2012 Indian coal mining controversy
2012
185,591.34 crore (US$33.78 billion)
India
Comptroller and Auditor General of India, the coal ministry, many electricity boards and private companies
Karnataka Wakf Board Land Scam
2012
200,000 crore (US$36.4 billion)
Karnataka
Uttar Pradesh NRHM scam
2012
10,000 crore (US$1.82 billion)
Uttar Pradesh
Mayawati
2G spectrum scam
2010
176,000 crore (US$32.03 billion)
national
Nira Radia, A. Raja, M. K. Kanimozhi, many telecommunications companies
Uttar Pradesh food grain scam
2003
35,000 crore (US$6.37 billion)
Uttar Pradesh
Kapil Sibal, Mulayam Singh Yadav, Mayawati
The total scope for just these five scams is nearly US $ 110 billion. Rs, 6,06,591 crores – imagine, Rs. 6,06,59,100,00,000. To put this figure in perspective, our Planning Commission had mandated that a villager earning above around Rs. 8,250 per annum will not be considered above the poverty level.
These are only 5 scams. This list does not contain major scams such as the recent Helicopter Scam (360 crore bribes paid), the Tatra Truck Scam involving 7,000 army trucks, the Antrix Devas deal, the Rs. 8,000 crore Satyam scam,  the massive CWG scam etc. Details of 246 scams are mentioned on this site.
One other thing is noteworthy about this list of scams. The scams listed per year are and show that the number of scams has been rising geometrically over the last three years:
2012: 41 scams
2011: 23 scams
2010:   9 scams
2009:   9 scams
2008:   6 scams
2007:   none
2006:   2 Scams
Not only the number of scams has increased, the quantum has reached astronomical figures. Clearly the enemy is becoming more and more fearless. And, why should they not become fearless? There is no risk of punishment. No one is held accountable. Almost all the main players involved in these scams are sitting pretty. They are even ministers and chief ministers. They control the investigative arms of the government and, even when the matter reaches our judiciary, cases drag on for decades, till these accused die of natural causes. So, why should the unscrupulous fear the law?
Much of our black money is stashed in property deals, gold and other assets in India itself. However, much of it is sent abroad. According to a Swiss Banking Association Report (2006), “India has more black money than the rest of the world combined.” In 2006, Indians had stashed almost $1,456 billion in black money in Swiss banks. Then there are banks in Mauritius, Channel Islands, the Far East and other tax havens. Imagine, just the Swiss bank balances spirited out of India till 2006 would have enabled $ 100,000 – Rs. 50 lakhs – to be spent on every individual Indian. And this is just till 2006. Would it not then be possible for us to fulfil our wish list for our country?
A report by Global Financial Integrity mentions that the Indian economy lost $123 billion in “black money” between 2001 and 2010. This is money that was illegally earned, transferred or used and stashed abroad.
Do you know how much India spends in a year in social services including healthcare and education? Just $ 3.6 billion. If we could have saved just 3% of the black money, we could have doubled our expenditure on health, education and welfare.
So this, my young fellow Indians, is the crux of the matter. You have a choice to do something about this or just let the enemy keep getting stronger. You are, in the true sense, the Bharat Bhagya Vidhata – the arbiter of India’s destiny.
What can you do to change things and to bring prosperity to India? You have your opportunity to bring about change now. The elections in various state assemblies are around the corner. The Parliamentary elections are scheduled in 2014. What you can do is this:
·      Register as a voter. Help get everyone in your family and friends get a Voter ID.
·      Scrutinise the background of all candidates. The information is available in their affidavits filed with the election commission and is a matter of public record, easily accessed on the EC’s website. Do not vote for anyone with a criminal record.
·      See the promises of political parties for what they are – mere promises. Compare them to the promises made before the previous elections – how many of these have been kept? Any political party which does not keep its poll promises lacks integrity.
·      See if the candidate or the party in question is trying to woo members of a certain religion or community by promising or giving special privileges. Such parties are divisive and cynical and best avoided.
·      Confirm your polling booth and the page number on which your name figures in the Voter’s list, before the Polling Day.
·      On Polling day, go out to vote. Also insist that all your friends and family go out and vote. Participation in our democratic process is no longer a luxury. It is a necessity. The black ink mark on your finger, certifying that you have voted, is one black mark you can be justifiably proud of. By not voting, you are playing in the hands of the cynical and corrupt.
·      Vote for those candidates who are sincere and honest and have a track record of working for the constituency and the people of India even when they are not in power.
·      Spread the word amongst other young people. Make them aware of the critical stage India is in. The tide in the affairs of Indians must not be allowed to go waste.
Why should you listen to me, especially since I am no guru?
The word guru comes from gu (darkness) and ru (light). A guru is one who leads you from darkness to light. I cannot lead you from darkness to light, from corruption to honesty, from sloth to activity, from childishness to maturity, from folly to wisdom. Only you can do that.
Yes, I am not a guru, but I am still relevant, for I am a mirror that shows the kind of image we project in the world today. If you do not like what you see, you can stop looking or you can do something about it.
I hope you will choose to act, for if you don’t. Your children will live in a worse India for what they see in the mirror, and what the world sees in it will become murkier and murkier. The choice, as usual, is yours.

Controversy on Vishwaroopam movie

The whole controversy on the movie Vishwaroopam by Kamal Hasaan was un-necessary. I am happy to hear that the Madras High Court has lifted the ban on the movie today.

VishwaroopamKamal Hasaan is a well respected actor and director in Indian film industry. The just released movie “Vishwaroopam” deals with Islamic terrorism. There have been several movies made in India on the similar theme, so what was the fuss about this? However, it seems without even watching the movie, Tamil Nadu’s Chief Minister Mrs J Jaylalitha decided to ban this. What was her concern: law and order situation or just pandering to some fringe voices? I will leave it to the readers to decide. Kamal Hassan called the ban “Cultural Terrorism” and I appreciate him taking a tough stand on this. He approached the court and finally court lifted the ban.

This is to be noted that the Film Censor Board had cleared this movie. That point should have factored heavily before Mrs Jaylalitha decided to go her way. But apparently, our politicians are obtuse in this manner.  As the ban was placed, it was good to see Leela Samson, head of the the Central Board for Film Certification coming to the defense of Hasaan. She rightly said: “It is absolutely unacceptable. We have certified hundreds and thousands of films…only with Vishwaroopam, you find it has not been done with due diligence? This is an infringement on freedom of expression.”

There was a major criticism on the ban via social media. Indians came out heavily at FB and Twitter to express their disgust on the ban by Tamil Nadu government. This is a good sign! As has been said: “Freedom is never free and liberty is never guaranteed.” Kudos to the judiciary for upholding the truth and Indian public that jeered the ban. I hope Mrs Jaylalitha will do some introspection too.

 

Violence against women: Feudal mindset at play

damini The Damini (actual name Jyoti) gang rape case in Delhi in December 2012 not only jolted the conscience of the whole India, it also became a global news. The whole incidence was characterized by  perverted barbaric acts by the group of 6 men, lapses in police surveillance and related law enforcement (fake address submitted by the owner of the bus). In the days and weeks to follow, massive protests by the public were symbolic of anger against the inefficient governance, insensitive statements by political, social and religious leaders of all colors and hues.  Very unfortunately, Damini ultimately succumbed to her injuries at a Singapore Hospital leaving behind a sense of guilt in all of us!

In a recent survey of G-20 nations, Canada has emerged to be the safest place for women to be in! And India is at the bottom of this list. USA stands at # 6.

Damini case raised intense debate in media over the status of women in our society. Is a woman safe in our country? The question is being raised as to why so many rape cases occur across India. One statistic data showed that every 40 minutes, a woman gets raped in our country. In the year 2011, there were about 25,000 cases of reported rapes all over India : Madhya Pradesh accounted for 14 % of all cases. Now you will agree that several of the cases are not even reported, hence the actual number might be much higher. And obviously, this data does not include the other forms of violence against women.

Why rapes happen?

In Indian (Hindu) society, we grow up worshiping goddesses like Parvati, Lakshmi, Durga. Our value system teaches us that women are to be treated with respect and humility. Yet, there is a disconnect. Significant disconnect, actually! The discrimination against women starts even in womb as exemplified by female feticide. We treat women as subservient to men: at birth, she is probably considered as the property of father, and after marriage, a property of husband. Similarly, dowry and domestic violence re other manifestations of this bias against women.  A usual Indian man can not generally stomach the idea that women too can have an independent existence. In other words, the feudal mindset in Indian males gets ingrained right from childhood when he experiences this at his home (sisters, other women getting less preferential treatment than men) and in outside world.

The horrific rape-case has ignited a debate all over the country demanding tougher laws and more accountable police. The central Govt has announced Justice Verma commission to undertake the judicial review of laws dealing with rape and related violence. Voices are also being raised that rape cases should be dealt in fast track courts.

Combating the menace of women violence requires a multi-pronged approach. It goes without saying that a stricter and efficient criminal justice system will be a great deterrent, but the societal reforms are equally needed. The things must start from home: giving women its due! In other words, gender equality and gender -sensitivity! Also, schools can help provide a balanced dose of health and sex education. NGOs should play a role in injecting the social input in the society on the overall issue of women’s rights and place!

I Save Lives Daily!


“I save lives daily.”
Are you a doctor?
No, because I am a vegetarian!

Do see the documentary ‘Our Daily Bread” by Nikolaus Geyrhalter. This silent documentary is a powerful depiction of how the food industry – vegetarian as well as meat- works in a high tech manner. Sensitivities of the animals are of least concern as we have a bigger task ahead: feed the humanity!

Recession Time in USA: Airline for Pets!

petsThe USA and the whole world is under economic recession. So is the news I hear all around and I am not doubting the veracity of this either! I am not an economic expert, but I can feel that the way jobs are being lost.

Whatever, but come July 2009 and you will see an airline service being launched exclusively for animals. Yes, for pets only! Pet Airways will fly only animals!
The website declares: “A Pet Airline where pets fly in the main cabin, NOT in cargo.”
Sounds wonderful!

Without offending animal lovers and animal right activists, I am amused at this news.
The web link is: http://www.petairways.com/

What a Simile: Corruption Vs Vegetarianism

The other day I was talking to one of my colleagues Vidya who grew up in USA but has keen knowledge of India and its affairs. The conversation veered towards democracy and ways to strengthen it. She obviously is very familiar with the corruption-infested Indian system. She even said that donating money for charitable cause in India is like putting money in a bag and throwing it in water: no one knows where it will end up. When I countered that despite all these odds, Indian has to come up with a credible system of deliverance if our democracy is to survive.

Our conversation continued. Not very impressed that corruption can be uprooted from India, she added: “Removing corruption from Indian system is like converting Americans to vegetarianism.”

I could not help laughing , but her observation has merit. Corruption has become a way of life for us. Undeniably, it has its pitfalls.

Moribund Judiciary means Limping Democracy

A person becomes sick and his condition is worsening rapidly. His family members take him to the emergency department of the local civil hospital. If it takes 3 days (I am just throwing up a number) for the emergency department to assess him and take next step, will you call it an effective Emergency Services? No, rather this will be a blot on the very term ‘Emergency’. If it takes courts years to decide a case of murder, will you call it a functional judiciary? Not at all!

The very concept of a democracy is existent on basic premise: where there is injustice, there shall be a redressal system. Hence, judiciary is sine-qua-non for a meaningful democracy. A sleepy and exhausted judicial system will result in a limping democracy. And that is precisely what is happening in India! The slow and over-burdened judicial system has failed to take adequate care of the grievances of the citizens. If a murder trial takes years to decide, it is tantamount to pushing the aggrieved party to immense physical and mental torture, leave alone punishing the victim to the desired extent.

Think about it! Where does lie the problem? Before I go into these issues, let me throw up a few common scenarios:

  1. Why do we have paucity of judges? When a district has number of hospitals (main civil hospitals to Community hospitals to Primary Health Centers) and hundreds of doctors to cater to the health needs of its population, can a single-digit number of judges tackle the legal health of the district?

    Why judges are such a scarcity? Rather why such a crisis is produced? Why judges are made such a precious commodity? Are they very costly to the system? No, they are like other gazetted officers, essentially affordable. It deifies any logicthat our judicial system is so severely understaffed.

    I remember a car accident involving my family member took 3 full years to be decided in a Haryana court. This is simply ridiculous. Looking at the pace of the case, I got a feeling that the whole judicial system had adopted a sadistic attitude, where both parties suffer endlessly. Believe me, it is totally un-necessary. We as a state and country can afford to make our judicial system more efficient.

  2. There is a perception that the judiciary has not been aloof from the virus of corruption. It raises more doubts when it is left to the State government to select judges for the district and lower courts.

    The solutions:

    1. Obviously, we need more courts and more judges to expedite the cases. A paralyzed judiciary is a great deterrent to the functional democracy.
    2. The judges should be selected by a centralized judicial commission and out- of – state postings should be a norm even at the lower courts.
    3. The judiciary should be free from political interference.

      A healthy judicial system will help our democracy to be more mature and transparent.

Tamilnadu Foundation Banned in USA

Today in a sensational news Times of India reports that the US has slapped sanctions on the charity group “amil Foundation”for its alleged involvement in fund-raising for banned LTTE. The Foundation has been designated under “Executive Order 13224”, which “targets terrorists and those providing support to terrorists or acts of terrorism,” the US Department of Treasury said in a press statement. The foundation is accused of raising money in the US in the name of charities, which ultimately ended up in the hands of LTTE.

It may be noted that Tamil Nadu foundation has been operating as a not for profit (NGO in Indian parlance) in America for many years and many of its Directors on the Board are well-established professionals (doctors, engineers). Dr.S.Palanisamy ( an MD) is its President. Others include: Vice-Presidents: Dr. S. Deivanayagam from Cookeville, TN (Tennesse), Dr. Parimala NathanTampa, FL 33647, Mrs. Mani ManoharanPittsburg, PA 15241. The Secretary is: Mr. P.K. Aravazhi from Naperville, IL 60564 (Ph: 630-430-2158).
The website is http://www.tnfusa.org/boardofdirectors.html but I am sure the website will close down sooner than later.

TN Foundation states its objectives as:
“NF’s objective is to help promote educational, social and other charitable projects in Tamil Nadu as part of a humble attempt by its members to share their fortunes with less fortunate people.It’s aim and objectives are distinctly different from those of the local cultural organizations. In fact TNF is the only organization in the world that is entirely devoted to the promotion of economic, and social welfare of the people of Tamil Nadu.What was started as a small attempt by a few individuals to offer their contributions to Tamil Nadu has evolved into a well-developed foundation through the dedication of several members throughout USA.”
It is hard to say what went wrong, but some of the patrons and donors may not be knowing what had been happening!